Thanks for sharing your thoughts. Unfortunately, I can't review the
quality and completeness of 100+ independent wikis all by myself, for
games I haven't played!
I can definitely make an alternate banner design, something smaller with
text like "Blah Wiki is an up-and-coming alternative to Blah Fandom.
Consider helping to edit a page there." If you or others can tell me
about and give examples of independent wikis that don't have as much
information as their Fandom counterparts, I can change those notices to
the other design.
You may also like to visit /wiki/Special:Statistics on each one to
compare the article count; note however that more articles doesn't
necessarily mean better quality info. For example, despite
pathofexile.fandom.com having more pages than poewiki.net, the fandom one
hasn't been updated to align with game updates, and is mostly useless for
current players:
https://r.nf/r/pathofexile/comments/1010kd5/its_happening_poewiki_is_starting_to_show_up/
https://r.nf/r/pathofexile/comments/10fxh0o/how_i_bricked_my_build_by_accidentally_looked_up/
Let me know your thoughts on this!